Experts say that the quantitative evaluation criteria for public toilet flies should not be blamed for formalism

A management rule is too hard to take too much for granted.

Nanchang public toilet flies no more than 3 is just a job requirement

Experts believe that quantitative assessment criteria should not be blamed for formalism

The Beijing Municipal Commission of City Administration has recently published the “Standards for the Management of Public Toilet Management Services in Major Industries in Beijing”, requiring that there be no more than two flies in public toilets. The “Nanchang City Management Standard (Trial),” implemented in Nanchang last year, stipulated that there should be no more than three flies in public toilets in the area strictly controlled. Sanya, a tourist city, stipulates that there must be no flies in public toilets.

The gap between a fly let the netizen's imagination exert itself. Some people laughed at such a rule that it was formalism. The reporter’s field survey in Nanchang found that this provision is not inappropriate as a measure of quantitative management evaluation, but it is difficult to accept too much of it to “interpret” it.

Public toilet environment is clean and tidy

On the morning of May 27th, at the Qiushui Square in Honggutan, Nanchang, the sun barely smiled, and visitors to and from public toilets continued. Although there was no flies in the past, there was an odor. According to the "Nanchang City Management Standard (Trial)" (hereinafter referred to as "Standard") implemented in August last year, it is strictly controlled area.

There are more than 280 public toilets in Nanchang City. The “Standard” clearly stipulates the environmental hygiene management standards for public facilities such as cleaning and cleaning, public toilets, garbage transfer stations, and fruit shell boxes in the strictly controlled area. It also specifies that there are no more flies in public toilets. 3, no fecal stains, urine alkali, no insects, no odor in the toilet.

The strict control areas all involve Nanchang's “face”, including 44 key roads such as Bayi Avenue and Beijing East Road, Honggutan Central District, Hongjiaozhou Area, and three key areas of High-tech Development Zone, Bayi Square, and trains. Station Square, Qiushui Square, Lujiang Citizen Park, and the main tourist attractions and waters in the city.

Afterwards, the reporter went to the public toilets at Yangming Park on the Yangming Road side and Bahao Alley Community on the Bayiqiao Street. From these public toilets, the overall environment is clean and tidy.

When it comes to why some public toilets are unsatisfactory, the director of the Xihu District Sanitation Facilities Maintenance Institute believes that lack of management funds makes it difficult to recruit excellent administrators. A small number of people do not care about hygiene. More and more pet owners will have a direct impact. Hygiene status of public toilets.

"Nanchang standard" is mandatory?

Xiong Zhiwei, deputy director of the Disease Control Center of Nanchang City, said that flies are often attracted by odors and are concentrated in poorly sanitised environments, contaminating food and spreading diseases. For the odor of public toilets, in addition to the olfactory feelings of the toilets, the intuitive manifestation is the number of flies.

According to the staff of the Environmental Management Office of the Nanchang City Management Committee, the number of flies is not an invention created by Nanchang and Beijing. Whether the Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development stipulates the management of public toilets or the selection of health districts (counties), there are clear regulations. All parts of the country are implemented according to standards. For example, the national standard “Health Standards for Public Toilets in Cities” established in 1998 puts out 0, 3, and 5 criteria for the number of flies in the first, second and third categories of toilets respectively.

Recently, the person in charge of the Sanitation Management Office of the Municipal Commission of Municipal Administration of Beijing Municipality stated that Beijing’s management service standards for public toilets are a work requirement, but it is not a mandatory standard and it is hoped that these public toilets will be guided to develop in a better direction. .

The person concerned explained that the "Nanchang City Management Standards (Trial)" was issued in the form of documents of the Nanchang Municipal People's Government. The probationary period is tentatively set for one year. It is also the basis for the assessment of Nanchang City's urban management work, and it is mandatory.

The "Standards" stipulates that public toilets must have management personnel and cleaning systems. The facilities are in good condition and they should be kept clean, tidy and hygienic. The reporter noted that the "Standard" as a management standard, there is no penalty rules.

Quantifying "flies" is not formalism

"Is there going to be public toilets flies? Otherwise, what is the significance of this mandatory provision?" Netizens "returned from the past," saying that this kind of stipulation seems to be meticulous, but it is actually not operational and is a form of formalism.

The person in charge of the Donghu District Waste Landfill Management Office, responsible for public toilet hygiene supervision, said that public toilets in Donghu District were contracted to a professional cleaning company for management. The usual supervision and inspection mainly depends on the overall health status, and it is generally not able to find the number of flies. .

“This is a quantitative indicator of performance assessment. Once public toilets are found to have heavy odors or flies, public toilets will be deducted from management scores.” The relevant person in charge of the Nanchang City Urban Management Committee said that every quarter will be conducted on the environmental sanitation of public toilets in the city. The assessment will not count the number of flies but will look at the overall health status.

However, the person in charge also admitted that the administrative executive power of public toilets is in various districts (counties). The personnel and finances of these management departments are independent of the Nanchang Municipal Urban Management Committee. Therefore, they can only request corrections or deductions within the scope of management. Minute.

"Quantitating flies in public toilets is not formalism but a form of management." On the 27th, Deng Hong, deputy director of the Institute of Sociology of the Provincial Academy of Social Sciences, believed that the digitization of public health management in public toilets is a manifestation of scientific spirit. People do not It should only be tangled in the number of flies themselves, but should see the advocacy of health standards, "so that it is easy for frontline managers to have at least a self-judgment on the merits of their work."

Next:Installation, use and regulation of marine diesel generator sets
Prev: The "Long March 3rd B" rocket wreckage fell to the residential area in Suining, Hunan